You need to build an SEO roadmap
Most SEO teams I talk to don’t have a roadmap; they have a list of things they want to do to improve SEO.
This week’s newsletter is sponsored by Foundation Marketing and Airops.
{sponsored} dofollow.com helps leading SaaS brands win visibility across Google and AI search. Every day you wait is another day competitors build authority. Book a call
Paid subscribers can download this template to draft SEO roadmaps
Most SEO teams I talk to don’t have a roadmap; they have a list of things they want to do to improve SEO. That’s just SEO busywork. The best analogy for this is a cross-country road trip. First off, as you plan this road trip, you know where you want to be and when the trip will end. The road trip itself is an adventure, so you don’t plan every stop and mile, but you have a general idea of what you plan to do. There’s plenty of room for chance and flexibility, but with a defined endpoint and milestones, you have guardrails for the adventure.
This is the way an SEO roadmap should be structured. What most teams call an SEO roadmap is akin to just getting in the car and driving. Nobody would actually do that with their vacation days. You wouldn’t burn a week of PTO by pulling out of your driveway and deciding at every intersection whether to turn left or right based on which direction looked more scenic in the moment.
[Sponsored by Airops]
Most SEO audits still check rankings. That’s the wrong instrument. Rankings don’t tell you whether AI models trust your content enough to cite it.
AirOps just published State of AEO 2026 on what actually predicts AI Search visibility, and a few numbers stood out. Pages updated in the last three months are 3x more likely to get cited than stale ones. Structured content with clean heading hierarchies sees 2.8x higher citation rates. And 85% of brand mentions in AI answers come from third-party sources, not owned pages.
The volatility data is the part worth sitting with. Brands earning both a mention and a citation are 40% more likely to resurface across answers. Most brands that drop out come back within two runs, if the signals are strong enough.
Carta saw a 7x increase in AI citations. Chime tripled theirs in four weeks.
The full report breaks down the mechanics behind both.
SEO needs to build to a crescendo
Bringing this back to SEO, this is precisely how most SEO teams operate every single quarter: Q2 doesn’t necessarily build on Q1, and Q4 is in a completely different place from the work done at the beginning of the year. SEO without a real roadmap is just treating a list of tactics as if the accumulation of activity were the same thing as progress toward a destination.
I have seen way too many of these faux roadmaps dripping with technical SEO. They have items like "Fix some title tags." Build a few backlinks. Refresh some old blog posts. Fix 302s. Fix soft 404s. None of that is wrong, exactly, but it doesn’t help progress towards a meaningful goal. In many of my consulting engagements, I can recommend that 404s be ignored or 302s be left alone because once we have defined a goal and built a roadmap, it’s clear that this busywork was a side quest to the real journey.
A spreadsheet with fifty rows, colored by priority, assigned to owners, with deadlines attached, feels like planning and looks official, but without the direction, it is not inherently valuable. Many times, I have asked the creator of these pieces of art where the company will be in 12 months after finishing all 50 rows; they usually can’t answer with anything more specific than stronger SEO.
Like a road trip, a real roadmap starts backward from a destination that has actual business meaning attached to it, something like a revenue target or market position. On a cross-country trip, you don’t optimize for driving the most miles or visiting the most gas stations. Too many SEO teams have completely inverted this, making the stop along the way the entire itinerary and forgetting there was ever a destination.
Here’s how to make a roadmap.
Start with the destination, not the tactics, and make that destination something a CEO would recognize as real. Not “improve rankings” and not “grow organic traffic.” Pick a goal that ties to revenue, or a market position you can point to and defend. A good goal is to become the site that appears first when a specific high-value buyer begins researching a category you actually want to own. A bad goal is a keyword target you can’t really control. It’s important that you can meaningfully reach that milestone because this is a real plan, not an opportunity for an excuse that you tried and failed.
Once you have that destination, work backward and place milestones along the way that are specific enough to fail. Ideally, these are SMART milestones. (see this post) Again, like the destination, these are real goals.
A task can always get marked done. Publish the article, done. But a milestone says something like “by the end of Q2, we should see a measurable lift in signups originating from this specific category of content,” and then you have to actually go check, and sometimes the answer is that it didn’t happen, and now you have to explain why instead of just pointing at a spreadsheet full of completed rows.
Have realistic milestones
Space those milestones so each quarter actually builds on the last, rather than standing as an island. Work that happens in Q3 must be reliant on what's shipping in Q1. As an aside, this is job security both for in-house teams and agencies because once your roadmap is accepted as the gospel, you are the driver of that goal. When you just have a task list, anyone can execute that.
If you can rearrange your quarters in any order and the plan still makes the same amount of sense, you don’t have a roadmap. You have task lists that just happen to be assigned to quarters.
With a roadmap in hand, you can now revisit your task list and backlog to see what work will contribute to your destination. None of this means throwing out flexibility to do tasks because a leader asked for it and it's good for your career, but it's helpful to know what you should be doing when you own the resource. You can most definitely deviate from your roadmap, but your important big rocks are scheduled and planned.
Roadmaps aren’t fixed
The roadmap process still allows for the algorithm update that impacted the site. A team with a real destination hears about an algorithm update and asks how it affects their path to it. A team with just a task list hears the same update and panics, building an entirely new list because there was never a destination they were working towards.
The teams I work with who actually do this well can tell you, at any point in the year, exactly how far along the trip they are and why the next stretch of road makes sense given everything that came before. The teams running task lists can tell you how many things they finished. Those are two very different conversations to be having with the people who control your budget.
As we close the first month of Q3, now would be the best time to plan out what you will do to meaningfully hit your goals over the next four quarters.
[Sponsored by Foundation Marketing]
94% of B2B buyers now use AI when researching software. So who’s AI citing when they look for tools like yours?
Well, it’s usually not you. We analyzed 57 million citations across 50 brands: only 2.2% of citations on early-stage buyer queries pointed to brand-owned domains.
Your SEO, PR, and social don’t fix this on their own. And we’ve learnt over the last 12 months that getting cited by AI is its own discipline. The Hidden Selection Phase report shows where AI pulls its answers from, and what separates the brands it cites from the ones it skips.
Download the report
Getting itchy and instead want to see where your brand stands? Book a call for a free content audit with the leading AI visibility agency for B2B.